CEO Advisor Newsletter October 2018
Critical Issues in M&A Transactions
These issues should be discussed with the buyer's or seller's team of advisors, which should consist of an M&A advisor, corporate/transaction attorney and tax advisor. This team of advisors will benefit any party in a transaction by hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars depending on the size and complexity of the transaction.
5 Critical Merger and Acquisition Transaction Issues
1. Cash vs. Earn Out vs. Seller Financing vs. Equity
The method of payment for a transaction, whether in cash or non-cash methods, may be a determining factor for both parties in consummating a transaction. The following are key factors to determine:
Cash. Cash is the most desired, most liquid and least risky method from the seller's side of the transaction. Cash tends to be the buyer's strongest position and should pre-empt rival bids better than equity or other methods. A strong seller can expect 50% - 70% cash in most cases, but don't count on 100% cash in a great majority of sales.
Earn Out. Since a company is a living, ever changing entity, most acquiring companies want to both incentivize and gain some assurance that the seller has a strong on-going concern and that the seller should be able to achieve its forecast in the future. An Earn Out involves quarterly or annual cash payments to the seller for achieving Revenue and/or Net Profit goals, as well as, other goals in some cases for a one to five year period. There are typically stipulations to achieving the Earn Out payments such as the founder(s) staying employed with the acquirer or other criteria.
Seller Financing. For most sellers, seller financing is far more favorable than an Earn Out, but most transactions do not include seller financing. In some circumstances, seller financing for a minor portion of the transaction can be more beneficial to the seller than the risk of an Earn Out and may suit both the seller and acquirer.
Equity. Equity involves the payment of the acquiring company's stock, issued to the stockholders of the seller, at a value relative to the seller's value. There are transaction costs and risk, as well as, tax implications to receiving stock as part of a transaction so both your M&A advisor and tax advisor should be consulted early in the process of the negotiations. The issuance of equity will generally provide more flexible deal structures and can be very lucrative to the seller in an up market.
2. Deal Structure
There are basically three methods for structuring a transaction:
A) Stock sale, B) Asset sale, and C) Merger. The seller and the acquirer have competing interests.
Primary issues relating to the deal structure are: (i) Limitation of liability, (ii) Third party consent requirements, (iii) Shareholder approval, and (iv) Tax consequences. You should work closely with your M&A advisor, attorney and tax advisor when discussing the best method of each transaction early in the sale process. Typically, privately-held companies are acquired as an Asset purchase.
Limitation of Liability. Unless negotiated otherwise, with a Stock sale, the seller's liabilities are transferred to the buyer as part of the transaction. Similarly, the surviving entity in a Merger will assume all liabilities of the other entity. With an Asset sale, only those liabilities that are designated as assumed liabilities are assigned to the acquirer, while the balance of the liabilities remain as an obligation of the seller.
Third Party Consents. To the extent that the seller's existing contracts have a provision against an assignment, a pre-closing consent to assignment must be obtained. No consent requirement exists for a Stock sale or Merger unless the contracts contain specific provisions against assignment upon a change of control.
Tax Consequences. A transaction can be taxable or tax-free depending upon the deal structure. Asset sales and Stock sales have immediate tax consequences for both parties. However, certain Mergers can be structured such that at least a portion of the sale proceeds can receive tax deferred treatment.
A) An Asset sale is most desirable to an acquirer, because a "step up" in tax basis of the assets occurs for the acquirer equal to the purchase price, which is typically the fair market value. This enables the acquirer to significantly depreciate the assets and improve profitability post-closing.
B) With a Stock sale, the selling shareholders pay long-term capital gains provided they owned the stock for at least a year. Additionally, the acquirer would have a cost basis in the stock purchased and not the assets, which would remain unchanged and cause an unfavorable result provided the fair market value is higher.
C) With a Merger, there is an opportunity to defer some (or possibly all with a merger of equals) of the tax liability whereby the value remains tax free until its eventual future sale.
Shareholder Approval. Selling shareholders are required to grant approval of a Stock sale. In most states, non-consenting shareholders of an Asset sale or Merger shall be entitled to exercise appraisal rights if they question the value of the deal and its terms.
3. Working Capital Adjustments
M&A transactions typically include a working capital adjustment as a component of the purchase price. The buyer wants to insure that it acquires a target with adequate working capital to meet the requirements of the business post-closing, including obligations to customers and creditors.
The seller wants to receive consideration for its assets that enabled the business to operate and generate profits. In terms of measuring the working capital, the agreement will include a method that compares the actual working capital at the closing against a target level established in the non-binding Letter of Intent.
4. Representations and Warranties
Both parties will be required to make certain negotiated representations and warranties about the business and the process of fulfilling the transaction. These representations and warranties should be taken seriously as any missteps in the post-closing period will result in the other party referring back to these provisions of the agreement with real consequences. Only promise what you can live up to. Gaining guidance from your M&A advisor and attorney will be extremely helpful.
5. Closing Conditions
A section of the transaction agreement will include a list of closing conditions which must be met in order for the parties to close the transaction. These are often negotiated at the time of the definitive legal agreement (although sometimes a detailed list will be included in the Letter of Intent).
These conditions may include, Board approval, the absence of any material adverse change in the seller's business or financial conditions, the absence of litigation, the delivery of a legal opinion from seller's attorney and shareholder approval. Additional provisions that are key to a transaction for an acquirer are non-competes and non-solicitation of employees and customers.
Well in advance of commencing the sale process, assemble your team of a seasoned M&A advisor, corporate/transaction attorney and tax advisor. Contact CEO Advisor, Inc., an M&A advisory firm with over 35 years of M&A experience.
How to Optimize the Value of Your Company and Sell Your Business at the Highest Price
CEO Advisor, Inc. is offering an exclusive, one-on-one M&A consultation at no cost. Take advantage of this opportunity to discuss the value of your business and an optimal exit strategy with our expert, Mark Hartsell, MBA, President. This discussion will include all critical aspects of selling your business for the highest price and best terms.
Call Mark Hartsell, MBA, President at (949) 629-2520 today for a no cost initial consultation.
Mark Hartsell's Credentials:
- Certified in Mergers & Acquisitions, Wharton Business School, University of Pennsylvania
- Master's Degree in Business, Loyola University; University of Maryland Undergraduate, Business Admin.
- 38 Years of Experience in Senior Management Positions, Mergers and Acquisitions, Business Consulting and Fund Raising
- Founded, Funded, Grew and Sold a SaaS (Cloud-based) Software Company to a NASDAQ Company (DRIV) in 2003
- President of CEO Advisor, Inc. (Business Consulting, Fund Raising, Mergers & Acquisitions) for the Past 15 Years; Has raised many millions of dollars of growth capital for clients, successfully bought and sold many businesses, and grown our client's sales, profits and value tremendously.
- Formulating an Exit Strategy
- Valuing Your Company
- The Sale Process
- Letters of Intent and Due Diligence
- Questions to Ask Before Selling Your Company
- Do the Numbers Add Up for You
- Indicators of the Best Time to Sell
CEO Advisor provides business consulting, growth capital and mergers and acquisitions advisory services affordably and effectively to meet the specific needs of CEOs and business owners of small to mid-size companies in a wide range of industries, including software, technology, media, professional service firms, healthcare, manufacturing and more.
CEO Advisor's mission is to advise CEOs, presidents, business owners and principal executives with the needed expertise and focus, coupled with hands-on advice and work performed to grow your business to the next level or realize your life's dream through a successful exit.